Harrington, S. (2012). Top Gear, Top Journalism: Three Lessons for
Political Journalists from the World’s Most Popular T.V show. Journal of Media & Cultural Studies, 24(6),
933-942.
Stephen Harrington, the author of this article, shares significant
insight into the reasons behind the success of the famous show, ‘Top Gear’ and
how these successes might be applied to enhance other forms of journalism. Harrington
credibility as an academic at the Queensland University of Technology, coupled
with his extensive use of scholarly sources in the piece makes this article
both insightful and convincing. In the article, Harrington points out some
shortcomings of political journalism, and argues that much of it is not freely
accessible to those that do not have the knowledge to engage in the subject;
therefore it does not reach its full consumer potential. With particular regard
to this, Harrington uses the show ‘Top Gear’ effectively to contrast and
reflect upon what political Journalism can improve on to better engage with its
audiences. Harrington’s references to particular episodes, and the application
of these examples to political journalism perfectly articulate the three points
of his argument; that by relating expert terminology to a common audience,
making things unconventional and making things fun, the show Top Gear may be
instructive to political journalist on how to better engage their audiences.
Hyland, T. (2012, May 13). Police
seek bigger picture in using drones but libertarians incensed. Brisbane Times. Retrieved from: http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/technology/technology-news/police-seek-bigger-picture-in-using-drones-but-libertarians-incensed-20120512-1yjgy.html
The author of
this piece, Tom Hyland, has adopted an informative approach to Victoria’s
consideration of using UAS, (Unmanned Aerial Systems) as a new form of police
surveillance. Tom Hyland’s reputation in military and police issues that have
been seen in his earlier works lend this piece the credibility needed to adopt
the factual tone it has used. In addition to this, all of the information
present was supported by other sources such as the Sky News Report on the same
story, making the information presented by Hyland reliable. Comparatively,
Hyland’s approach is more detached from the ‘right or wrong’ viewpoint that
other sources such as Sky News projects. Furthermore, Hyland’s extensive use of
sources from both sides of the argument such as libertarian groups and police
spokespeople, present a well balanced view of the topic. This, in addition to
the informative approach of the article, makes the information accessible,
unbiased and credible. The negative side of this approach is that it has
limited the viewpoints of the supporting and opposing arguments that can be
seen in the undercurrents of the story. Despite
this, the piece is still largely unbiased and credible, making it a
recommendable source on this topic.
Sky News.
(2012, May 14). Victoria police assessing drone aircraft. Retrieved from http://www.skynews.com.au/tech/article.aspx?id=749777&vId=3249901
From the
beginning of the Sky News report, the author (unstated in the piece), promotes
a one-sided argument against the use of drones by Victorian police. Sky News,
unlike Hyland, has adopted the ‘against’ viewpoint and they explore it well,
calling upon both civil libertarian and state-opposition groups to support
their opposing argument. Despite this, the piece fails to demonstrate any
attempts at exploring a ‘for’ viewpoint, and its lack of sources and abundance
of one-sided material articulates the fact that the author is largely biased.
Sky News has taken on a persuasive approach to this story and from the opening
section has attempted to criticize the use of drones by Victorian Police.
Despite this, their approach is well-argued and whilst it is entirely one-sided,
it still presents key information about the story. From this, it is determined
that whilst the biased viewpoint the author has adopted limits arguments seen
in other sources, it is still reliable to the extent that the information
present is accurate. With that being said, Sky News’s one-sided report, in
comparison to Hyland’s impartial approach is less credible on the grounds that
it does not explore any viewpoint that is not their own.
Sandilands,
B. (2012, May 14). Plane talking: drones vs. criminals, or citizens? A
difficult debate begins. Retrieved from http://blogs.crikey.com.au/planetalking/2012/05/14/drones-v-criminals-or-citizens-a-difficult-debate-begins/
Ben Sandilands’ blog, ‘Plane Talking’ recognises the impact that
aerial drones could have on civilian life. From the opening lines, the piece
takes on a satirical approach and stresses the privacy implications that would oppose
the use of drones. This is mostly done through substantial exaggeration of
possible scenarios, such as a drones spying on ‘couples snogging in the park’. However,
the nature of the piece being a blog permits and even encourages the use of
humour, and Sandilands’ satirical approach is effective in getting the message
across. Sandilands also outlines possible risks associated with drones that
were not addressed in earlier pieces, including the potential risks to domestic
flights that sky-drones might propose. In addition to this, the medium of the
article and its interactive capabilities allowed for additional comments to be
made by readers, something that was not possible in the Sky News or Brisbane
Times reports. This use of public opinion on the blog allowed for a more collective
view of the subject, and by doing this the blog was able to explore arguments
that weren’t present in the original piece. Despite this, the article takes on
the approach of assumed knowledge, and consequently it would be difficult to understand
if no prior knowledge was known about Victoria’s involvement in drone technology.
In addition, no hard facts or primary sources were used in the piece and the
lack of evidence or a professional opinion made the piece severely opinion-based.
With that being said, the media format is a blog, and it is uncommon for such
material to be present in such a medium.
No comments:
Post a Comment